Chopstick Negotiations

By Christine Cox | Fall 2015

Printer Friendly

The signature assignment of Father Eric Zimmer’s EMBA Negotiations class is a trade up that perfectly illustrates the “bigger pie” theory.


Zimmer gives each student something inexpensive, such as a pencil or a pair of chopsticks. He instructs them to make five trades with people who are not in the class or close family and friends. The goal is to trade for items that are more valuable than the pencil or chopsticks, but to negotiate in a win-win manner.

Results are often spectacular. For instance, Maria Bailey’s classmates traded up for such items as:

• A riding lawn mower

• A suite at the Indianapolis Motor Speedway

• A kayak

• A dirt bike

• A baseball autographed by Hall of Famer Ryne Sandberg.

Beyond that, Bailey used the exercise to benefit the EMBA International Immersion experience, a weeklong course in which students apply their knowledge in a global setting. Teams are matched with companies or organizations with a social cause and begin working with them closely in the months before the trip.

EMBA Team 9 — Bailey and classmates Steve Carollo, Dustyn Arney, Ryan Cushing, Stephen Smith and Pat Meyer — headed to Uganda in June 2015. They were paired with Pulse, a company that manufactures The Village Ambulance, a lightweight medical trailer that can be pulled by bicycles, motorcycles or by hand to serve people in rural communities. Each trailer saves an average of two lives per week, and 50 percent of all patients are expectant mothers.

Using the handle 5TradesAway, Team 9 auctioned its final chopstick trades on Facebook to raise money for Pulse. The three-hour auction on May 5 raised $21,000, attracted 500 bidders generated seven million Twitter impressions and may have created a permanent
fundraising platform.

“The project just grew and grew,” Bailey says. “Other people wanted to try it for themselves. So we bought chopsticks and handed them out. In the end, 55 people traded chopsticks for items for our auction.”

The 56 auctioned items included a vacation rental in Martha’s Vineyard that brought in $3,500; a Louis
Vuitton purse that fetched $650; and tickets to Chicago Bears preseason football game that sold for $350.

In all, the auction raised $11,000 and an anonymous Notre Dame family matched $10,000. The event was so successful that nonprofit groups have written to Bailey about benefitting from future events, and she anticipates 5TradesAway continuing.

Father Zimmer sees the exercise as the embodiment of a successful negotiation. “When you hitch the exercise to a higher cause and communicate your intentions, then people want to negotiate,” he says. “They’re happier to give larger items and fully engage because they are contributing to the well-being of others. This is the bigger pie.”

Related Items


  • Salt and Light12
    Salt & Light 4900
    The Amato Family: Fancy Pants 4910
    Holly Powers: The Power of One 4901
    Mike Anello: The Buzz 4908
    Karen Kenny: They Can’t Take That Away from Me 4902
    John Greenwald: Garage Band on a Mission 4904
    Kevin Kreutner: Adopting a Country 4906
    Matt Knott: The Circle of Faith 4909
    Stephen Keppel: What a Difference a Year Makes 4907
    Thomas Jindra: The Mustard Seed 4903
    Marissa Gebhard: The Buddy System 4905
    More Salt & Light 4911
  • Class Notes1
    Alumni Community: Class Notes 4935
  • Ask More of Business1
    Mendoza Student Leadership Association (MSLA) 4958
  • Mendoza News10
    AIMING FOR A Legacy 4836
    A Global Vision 4837
    Happy Feat 4891
    "I Raised My Hand" 4888
    Training Intuition 4887
    A Closer Look at the Numbers 4890
    Pie for Everyone 4898
    Chopstick Negotiations 4899
    That Gummy Bear is Calling Your Name 4892
    Mendoza Welcomes New Faculty 5087
    An Unplanned Return: Bill Schmuhl Jr. 4838
  • Mendoza Profiles3
    The Right Time 4929
    A Tanzania Adventure: Mt. Kilimanjaro 4930
    IT Girl 4933
  • Alumni Community5
    Alumni Community: Class Notes 4935
    Three Brothers/One Mission 4936
    Andria Seneviratne: A Leap of Faith 4937
    Perry Dellelce: A Canadian Ambassador For Notre Dame 4938
    Eric Huang: Fitting 4939
    In Memoriam 4940
  • First Person2
    Gulf Coast Motels and the Second Coming 4941
    Thoughts of Ted 4956